Successful commercial lending decisions rely on timing, vigilance, and control. While lenders cannot influence interest rates or the broader market, they can control how quickly they respond when loans begin showing signs of stress. From our experience working with the most successful lenders, proactivity by those lenders clearly is essential. Those lenders who achieve the best outcomes have the tools to identify early warning signs which allow them to engage with their borrowers to implement strategic workout solutions to avoid and/or mitigate foreseeable risks that could trigger potential loan defaults.
Below are the seven most common warning signs lenders should monitor to prevent a default.
7 Early Warning Signs That a Loan May Require a Workout
1. A Pattern of Late Payments
A single late payment does not suggest that a borrower is in trouble and is likely to default under the loan. However, a pattern of late payments over time often signals financial strain on the part of the borrower and/or the income-producing collateral property. Lenders have the ability to build into their loans tools that will help them detect whether the loan parties and/or the property are facing serious problems, including: (a) monitoring payment patterns; (b) staying in close contact with the borrower; (c) receiving frequent updated financial reports about the property and the loan parties; and, (d) conducting regular property inspections.
Lenders who use these tools can spot potential problems long before they bloom into disasters allowing them to intervene early enough to develop a workout plan, i.e., an extension, modification or forbearance agreement, to maintain the subject loan as a performing asset. By doing this, the lender can avoid having to work out the loan following the occurrence of a loan default.
2. Covenant Breaches
Whether it’s debt coverage ratios, minimum occupancy thresholds, loan-to-value tests, or net worth, liquidity, or other financial tests, one or more covenant breaches are often early indicators of operational problems or financial challenges. Early detection of these situations allows lenders to address them in a way that can strengthen, or at least stabilize, the situation.
3. Falling Debt Service Coverage Ratios (“DSCR”)
When a collateral property’s DSCR dips below the lender’s financial covenant requirement, it signals a shift in underlying economic factors. This change is often an early sign that a borrower’s cash flow may soon be insufficient to cover loan obligations. Quick action can include revisions to the loan terms through a short-term modification to keep the loan performing, or a rebalancing of the loan with a mandatory principal paydown by the borrower, as described below in section 4.
4. Declining Property Values
Weak comps, rising cap rates, or stalled rent growth can quietly erode collateral value. Including a loan-to-value (LTV) ratio test in the loan documents allows a lender to measure the collateral property’s value against the loan amount. This test demonstrates whether there is sufficient equity in the collateral property to protect the lender’s security interest. Early intervention through an LTV test can reveal a concerning decline in collateral value. When the collateral value relative to the outstanding loan amount exceeds a designated covenant threshold, the loan documents can provide remedies to protect the lender’s interests. These protections may include requiring the borrower to pay down principal to rebalance the loan and satisfy the LTV ratio test.
5. Major Tenant Turnover
Losing a key tenant or failing to renew a lease can rapidly destabilize a property. Adding a financial covenant that requires the borrower to maintain sufficient reserves for tenant improvement and leasing commission costs related to potential future re-tenanting during the loan term can help mitigate this risk. Identifying and addressing, in the loan documents, the protections available to the lender and the property in the event of likely disruptions to the collateral property’s economic performance is essential in this market.
6. Silence or Vague Communication
Delayed or missed financial and/or property updates, or vague responses to direct questions from the lender about the financial condition of the loan parties and/or the collateral property, often signal that a borrower is disguising or delaying bad news. Proactive lenders reach out and meet with the borrower and any guarantor(s), and may even visit the collateral property. These lenders offer structured support and design modification agreements that increase the likelihood the borrower can repay the loan in full and, ideally, on time.
7. Incomplete or Delayed Financial Reporting
Delayed or inconsistent financial reporting – whether relating to any loan party(ies) or any of the collateral assets – rarely results from simple administrative errors. Often, it signals emerging financial stress on the loan party(ies) or the collateral property. Early engagement, as soon as a borrower fails to meet financial reporting requirements, allows lenders to structure modifications, forbearances, or other remedies before the situation escalates to a point where full repayment of the loan is at risk.
Why Spotting Warning Signs Early Is Important
Spotting early warning signs on their commercial loans gives lenders a critical advantage in managing potential or actual risks and protecting their loan portfolios. By identifying problems before they escalate, lenders can take early action, which may include any of the following:
- Restructure the loan terms to align with the borrower’s current cash flow challenges in exchange for new lender protections, such as a pledge of new additional collateral, new or additional guaranties and other similar matters.
- Update the collateral documentation to mitigate potential exposure by bolstering the lender’s rights and controls over the collateral property in exchange for modified loan repayment terms to improvement the probability that the loan will be repaid in full.
- Guide a borrower toward workout solutions such as forbearance or loan modification that are practical and realistically address the actual factors negatively impacting the collateral property and/or the loan parties’ financial strength.
The earlier these steps are evaluated and a course initiated, the greater the opportunity that the final solution will preserve collateral value; maintain the borrower’s capacity for solid financial performance; develop a strong relationship with each borrower that successfully pays and performs its loan obligations in full; and reduce the likelihood of the default of each and any loan.
Head of Business Strategies & Partnerships
